Strange attachment problems

I’ve run into an interesting problem with attachments with one of my users. I don’t think it’s a lotus problem.

User gets an excel attachment from an external person but can’t open the file. Basically the file is unrecognized.

Looking at the attachment you can see the text information of the excel file.

The sender claims no one else has this problem. I believe the sender is using a mac and some version for the mac. The sender sends in various formats from excel ver 2 to 95 - 2000, etc. All of which doesn’t work.

I asked the sender to send an attachment to my corporate email and hotmail account.

Here’s what I found

domino/lotus notes 6.5 - doesn’t work

outlook express - hotmail (http connector) - doesn’t work

outlook 2003 - microsoft lotus notes connector - doesn’t work

www.hotmail.com - doesn’t work

outlook 2003 - hotmail (http connector) - WORKS!

forwarded from outlook 2003 hotmail to corporate - WORKS!

so I dumped and did a crc/sfv check on the files

SFV file successfully created (5 files processed) …

C:\temp5>type temp5.sfv

; Generated by WIN-SFV32 v1.1a (pure-sfv v0.3) on 2005-09-19 at 15:52.36

;

; 16934 13:02.46 2005-09-19 hotmail.xls

; 16934 12:49.44 2005-09-19 lotus notes.xls

; 16934 13:01.36 2005-09-19 oe.xls

; 16784 13:00.00 2005-09-19 outlook2003.xls

; 16934 13:59.00 2005-09-19 outlook2003-lotusconnector.xls

hotmail.xls 920E3E0B

lotus notes.xls 920E3E0B

oe.xls 920E3E0B

outlook2003.xls 4FA593BC

outlook2003-lotusconnector.xls 920E3E0B

as you can see there’s an extra 150 bytes on the non working ones

I’m guessing that the sender claims no one else has this problem because most people the sender sends to probably use outlook.

Has anyone run into this problem?

Subject: strange attachment problems

Did you ever get a resolution to this problem? I’m running into the same type of issue, where the file works in some internet mail cases, but not if it’s sent directly to my corp. account. Thanks.

Daniel