One reports that when a customer opens a Notes database in Domino Designer and selects Tools > Recompile All LotusScript, Domino Designer hangs during the first compiler pass. The support says that the software is DESIGNED IN THAT WAY:http://www-1.ibm.com/support/docview.wss?rs=463&context=SSKTMJ&context=SSKTWP&dc=DA490&dc=DB520&dc=DA4A30&dc=DB530&dc=DA480&dc=D700&dc=DB500&dc=D400&dc=D600&dc=DA400&dc=D420&dc=DA4A10&dc=D410&dc=DA4A20&dc=DA460&dc=DA440&dc=DA430&dc=DA470&dc=DB550&dc=D430&dc=DA420&dc=DA500&dc=DA410&dc=DB540&dc=DB510&q1=dependency+tree&uid=swg21197609&loc=en_US&cs=utf-8&lang=en
Subject: NOTES IS DESIGNED TO HANG IN SPECIFIC SITUATIONS!
Oh for pity’s sake !
Before you post alarmist rubbish like this why don’t you consider the full story - and then if you still decide to proceed in posting this tripe at least give people the full details.
The report goes on to say: “The issue was specific to a script library which was in a unexpected state; it was possibly manipulated by a third party application.”
Personally - if my script libraries had been manipulated by a third party then I wouldn’t want them to recompile! Admittedly - despite the fact that it is understandable that Designer might become unstuck by ‘unexpected states’ it should handle the exception better. But it’s hardly the “I MUST TELL THE WORLD IN CAPITALS” issue that you are making out.
Subject: WHERE’S YOUR SENSE OF HUMOUR
Some how I don’t think it was serious post ![]()
Subject: NOTES IS DESIGNED TO HANG IN SPECIFIC SITUATIONS!
Nice, I am not surprised ![]()
- Johan
Subject: NOTES IS DESIGNED TO HANG IN SPECIFIC SITUATIONS!
I think you’re badly misinterpreting that. Notes (or, for that matter, any other software) is no more “designed to hang” than my car is designed to run into lamp posts, but if I happen to steer it in the direction of one, my car is working as designed when I crash. The problem is that Notes was handed some oddly munged code, probably by a third party program, the result of which was the client hanging. To put it another way, the third party program was affecting the context of Notes’s operation, yanking on the steering wheel as it were. So the problem, it seems to me, is not some sort of bizarre intentionally inserted design flaw; it’s the intervention of outside factors which, because they may themselves be poorly designed to interact with Notes, ultimately cause a problem when Notes keeps doing what it’s supposed to.
Which is not to say that the software is without flaws, of course, but to take this apparently isolated problem and conclude from it alone that there are profound design flaws is overreaching.
Subject: NOTES IS DESIGNED TO HANG IN SPECIFIC SITUATIONS!
The point is that:1. Even in erroneous situations the system should behave in a controlled way and the user should be informed appropriately about the system’s state. In this case I expect the Designer to display a message box that says something like “Can not perform the operation bla bla bla…”
- Mishandling of such situation is a bug and therefore I expect the support to say something other than just “it is working as designed”.
I spent about a four hours just trying to understand what’s wrong (no third-party tool was involved in my case), now I know that it is just another “Notes bug” and how to deal with it …
It is very pity to discover from time-to-time such “surprises” that are “working as designed”. Isn’t it?
Subject: RE: NOTES IS DESIGNED TO HANG IN SPECIFIC SITUATIONS!
A Notes developer performing a “recompile all Lotuscript” is hardly a novice user that needs handholding by the application. That is exactly the target audience that should be capable of performing the search on the IBM support database that you’ve pointed to.